TOUR REVIEWS

August 11th - White River Amphitheatre - Auburn, WA, U.S.

Paul Jarolimek:

I wanted to drop you a line concerning this show.  Before I get to the show itself let me give you (and your viewers, if you do decide to post this) just a little background as to my perspective on what happened there.

I have been listening to Black Sabbath since 1979 having been introduced to them by a well meaning Christian music teacher who during school lunch breaks in my sixth grade class showed videotapes of the 700 Club shows warning of the Devil's influence in rock music.  Needless to say, it had the opposite effect on me since up until that time the hardest rock music I had listened to was Donnie Osmond...lol.

As the show was droning on, I was furiously copying the names of these "evil" bands and as soon as I could I went out and bought as many albums as I could.  I ended up with Judas Priest, Blue Oyster Cult and 'We Sold Our Souls for Rock and Roll' by Sabbath.  While I enjoyed the rest of the bands and developed a fondness for others such as Deep Purple and Iron Maiden, Sabbath absolutely out-shined them by the proverbial country mile.  My Father had the most difficult time with me listening to this horrible sound coming from our basement, but my Mother, bless her, decided that any band who could put out a song such as 'Laguna Sunrise' couldn't be all bad and I was allowed to continue listening.

This led to a life long appreciation of the band to which all others were compared.  A few years back, Rob and I met on-line and over the course of time I began assisting him in researching and digging to find out the true history of this band...  I had thought I knew quite a bit, but the revelations discovered over the last few years astounded me and gave me a much deeper appreciation of the band than ever before.  Amazingly, although I have over 500 recorded concerts, I have never seen the band, in any incarnation, play live.  The closest I came was Ozzy solo with Geezer on bass in 1988...

Because this research was so all consuming and took a great deal of time in front of the computer my eldest daughter (she is 10 now...) would spend time with me at the computer, watching and listening and apparently developed an appreciation of the band I had no knowledge of...  I didn't find this out until we were watching a cartoon about 3 months ago where the father and daughter were at a concert together and my daughter turned to me and said, "You wouldn't take me to a concert would you?"  I said "Sure I would, Honey.  Who would you like to see?"  Thinking how much I love my daughter since I was sure it would be Britney Spears or some other airhead bubblegum music like that...but she surprised me...

"Black Sabbath" she said...

There couldn't be a prouder Father in the world at that point - LOL.  So we went to Ozzfest '05 and when I sat down to write this today my thoughts were to write a true critique of the show.  But as I thought more about it I realized there can be no criticism.  None.  While the opening bands were great (Zombie and Iron Maiden were just plain fun to watch - Black Label Society's new album is a must buy) there was one reason we were there and it was to see Sabbath...  For me, finally...   For her, the first time a seeing live band.

Being able to watch my daughter nearly in a trance, vibrating with awe at the spectacle and volume...  Hearing the opening notes of "N.I.B."  seeing Ozzy, Geezer, Bill and of course Tony, doing what they clearly love to do transcended anything I have ever experienced.  I have read that they are only out touring because of the money.  Rubbish, I say.  Obviously those whose opinion is such do not realize just how hard 35 YEARS of touring would be (separately and together).  In the early years, 2 or 3 shows a night.  Later, huge stadium shows with tens of thousands of people (hundreds of thousands in the case of Live Aid) and now a constant schedule for nearly the last 10 years.  You simply would not, nay, could not, do such a thing unless you purely loved what you do.  And it showed.  I felt it and  my daughter felt it.

Were there flaws musically?  Sure.  Most notably, Ozzy's voice did fail during the final verse of "Dirty Women" and he got frustrated, threw his mic down and went off the stage while the band played the outro of the song.  However, he got a large cup of tea (yes - hot tea) and came back out and asked the crowd if they still wanted them to play despite his vocal problems.  The crowd's reaction was enormous and it looked for all the world like it surprised Ozzy.  I believe, like all artists, that they want to put on the best show possible and that is where the frustration shown by Ozzy came from, but when the crowd in their response showed him that despite the foibles of age and years of touring we appreciated what they set out to do and it really did not matter it was "perfect".

The band relaxed and finished a truly amazing set.  They played the song "Black Sabbath" with nearly 20,000 fans with lighters and Ozzy looking like a man possessed...  The crowd singing ever other line of "War Pigs" back to Ozzy...  The thunder of Bill's bass drum opening Iron Man...  Geezer's amazing finger work on the light blue bass he switched to for "Children of the Grave"...  Tony playing the opening notes to "Apache" and seamlessly moving into "Sleeping Village"...  There really are not words to describe it all...

I think it would serve all of us to take a bit of a reality check here and note that these guys are in their mid-50's and things don't work as well as they do when you are in your 20's.  Besides, if your want perfect go buy the studio albums, all musicians - all - have errors, make changes, can't perform the same as the studio version when they play live.  Since when did anyone want a band to perform exactly like they do on the album? That's not the point of the live show.  It's the energy, the showmanship, the raw good feelings and excitement that comes from seeing a band like this so steeped in history - pioneers of an entire genre of music - that is why we are there...

I know one 10 year old girl who will forever remember Ozzy, Geezer, Bill and Tony - not for the "faults" some are wont to point out, but for who they are...

Black Sabbath - The Greatest Band Ever

[Editor's note - I want to thank Paul for sharing his perspective on the show.  When he told me about seeing this much maligned show in Auburn on the phone recently, I was very surprised at how differently the media has been portraying it.  When Paul was able to, he dedicated himself to Sabbath research just as vigorously as I have been.  Knowing this, I really wanted him to share his perspective on the Auburn show.   Sabbath has never been about playing note-for-note renditions of their studio albums.  Instead, it's the amazing vibe that these 4 men create when they step on stage together.]


David Rostowsky:

Well, my ears are still ringing this morning. I had a blast at Ozzfest!

Where to start with Sabbath?  Let me preface by saying I've seen all the Sabbath incarnations over the years (Ozzy, Dio, Gillan, Martin, etc) and I can't think of a worse (if not a little embarrassing) performance than last night.  I was embarrassed for Sabbath when I saw Tony and the 3 Stooges on the Forbidden Tour play in front of about 100 people in Tacoma WA.  I thought they were reduced to be a cheap bar band at the time and done.  However, they played that gig tight.  Last night's performance had its high points along with some really low points.  Suffice to say, Ozzy's not recovered yet and I think last night just shot his mental attitude utterly.  If anything might drive Bill back to drinking it might be last night, ha.  They started out GREAT though!!!!

N.I.B.
========
I took a video of this just so I could see if Ozzy was recovered and feeling like himself.  They nailed it!  The band looked confident.  Ozzy looked like he felt really good.

After Forever
==================
They really jammed on this song.  Ozzy still sounded great.  You could tell they were really kicking ass. I love hearing this song live.

War Pigs
==================
The first chinks start to form in their armor.  The band played the song well, but whoever was running Ozzy's vocal effects should be fired.  There was about a 3-5 second delay put on the end of each line in the verse so it sounded like this - "Generals gathered in their masses!" DA-DA! "...in their masses!!!!"  It was
really awkward sounding.  Ozzy stuttered the first few times because it threw his timing off, but smiled it off and powered through the song.

Dirty Women
===================
HA.  What can I say?  The show ALMOST ended right here.  Ozzy's voice was awful.  He was making Peter Brady's voice changing episode sound like Pavarotti.  The "Walking the streets..." part is where cats were getting stepped on.  You couldn't make yourself sing that badly.  Voice was shot!  I quickly whipped out my camera and starting taking video it was so bad.  I started filming about 5 seconds before Ozzy threw down the mic and stormed off stage completely pissed off!  

[Editor's note: David sent me a video clip of this exact moment, but I decided it was way too sad and embarrassing to post.  It was a very disheartening moment, both for Ozzy AND his fans.  Considering the press release Ozzy made the following day about not performing any more Ozzfests, I do believe David unknowingly filmed a sad turning point in the bands history.]

Fortunately, it was right before Tony's solo.  I was waiting for the lights to go down and the band to follow at that point.  The band was confused and clearly embarrassed, but Tony went into an extended solo and they did their best to go on.  After a long solo, Tony finishes and Ozzy walks back on.  The band strikes up a slow melodic part again and Tony soloed a bit more.  Ozzy starts screaming and trying to get the crowd going.  They finish the song pretty sloppily.  Ozzy says, "Guess what I'm <crack> gonna do?  My voice is fucked up again tonight.  So Ill continue croaking
on if you don't mind listening.  What do you say?"  Crowd roars!

Fairies Wear Boots
====================
Ozzy's clearly completely shot mentally and the band pretty much followed suit not knowing if Ozzy can talk let alone sing.  The tempo of the song seemed more plodding and slower than I'm used to hearing too.

Medley: Symptom, Sweet Leaf, Funeral
============================== =========
I don't think much of the song snippet so I wont detail that.  Ozzy was basically talking the lyrics trying to find himself.  I got the impression that they just wanted it all to end right there.  Ozzy was all over the place on the timing and lyrics.  He was still rattled.

Iron Man
==================
Ozzy screwed up and continued singing right when the whole band was going up-tempo for Tony's solo.  Amazingly, the entire band cranked right back into the verse in perfect unison.  That was impressive as they were about 4 notes already going up-tempo before Ozzy started singing.  After that verse, then they went up-tempo for real and did Tony's solo.  The song seemed sloppy.

Black Sabbath
=====================
Ozzy gets a 2nd wind.  I took a video of this song.  They nailed it perfectly.  You could see Ozzy thinking "he was back."  They played this song great!!!

Sabbath Bloody Sabbath [intro] / Paranoid
============================== ===============
Voice goes out again.  The band pretty much rushes through it.  The end of the show is in sight!

Encore: Sleeping Village [intro] / Children Of The
Grave
============================== ==============
Without much of a curtain call they jump into this quick.  Ozzy's voice is gone.  He's pretty much talking the lyrics.  The band played this well despite Ozzy's vocals.  End of show, they rush off stage.

I was a bit sad, amused, and disappointed at the same time.  Not nearly as good as last years Ozzfest performance.  I was wondering who was saying Ozzy looked healthy?  When he took his shirt off, good Lord!  He might have ribs on the upper chest (no muscle), but he had a gut!  He looked like a 60 year old with
tattoos up there.  Laughable.  Almost made Bill look fit.  By the way, is Bill sporting his beard again?

Live Pictures by David Rostowsky


Powers of darkness fail Ozzy in Auburn (by Ernest A. Jasmin for The News Tribute - 8/12/05)


Hell almost breaks out at Ozzfest after Ozzy's voice 'blows out'

By TRAVIS HAY

Since rock n' roll is the Devil's music, it's only appropriate that all hell almost broke loose at Ozzfest Thursday night at White River Amphitheatre.

During the fourth song of headliner Black Sabbath's set, Ozzy Osbourne angrily tossed the microphone stand to the ground and left the stage in a state of frustration mid-song during "Dirty Women" after his voice began to constantly crack.  While it humorously sounded like the 56-year old Osbourne was going through a second puberty, it was clear something serious was happening.

Osbourne later explained that his voice was "blown out" and gave the crowd an ultimatum.  "I'm willing to stay ... if you're willing to listen."  Everyone listened.

From there the band broke into "Fairies Wear Boots" and other Sabbath classics.  Ozzy, who appeared rather jubilant, jogged, jumped and bounced up and down while singing.  Even though his throat was hurting him (he winced while screaming several times) he played through the entire set.

The show marked Osbourne's first appearance since postponing a Wisconsin Ozzfest stop last week because he was having throat problems.  Sabbath has canceled and rescheduled other dates on the tour due to health problems and this recent throat catastrophe could signal the end of Sabbath's Ozzfest days.

However, if Sabbath had to end its set short, fans would have got the most metal for their money.  In Flames, Arch Enemy, Shadows Fall, Killswitch Engage and 15 other bands were on the bill.

Dressed in a red and black clown suit with fake blood dripping onto his face from the top of his skull, mohawked Mudvayne vocalist Chad Gray came on stage looking like the most psychotic clown since Steve King's "It."  All clowning aside, Mudvayne played plenty of devilishly good songs from its catalog including excellent new album "Lost and Found."

Metal legends Iron Maiden played a 75-minute set that, given Ozzy's throat problems, was hands down the best performance of the day as well as the most entertaining.  With a set list culled from the band's first four albums, singer Bruce Dickinson and his band belted out "Run for the Hills," "Number of the Beast" and many Maiden standards.  The combination of a spry Dickinson and props including a gigantic version of the group's zombie-demon mascot Eddie made for an over-the-top showing.

Ozzfest's second stage has a reputation for showcasing metal's next big thing.  This year's next big thing is Mastodon, which delivered an impressively thrashing set of ear-pounding metal.  Second-stage headliner Rob Zombie played a career-spanning set that showcased the abilities of his new guitarist John 5 (formerly of Marilyn Manson).

The night ended with Sabbath's one-two punch of "Paranoid" and "Children of the Grave," on the main stage.  If it was the band's last performance on the tour, the two songs made for a great way to go out.


Travis Hay is a freelance journalist in Seattle. He can be reached at travhay@yahoo.com.

Festival Lineup

Main Stage:

IN FLAMES
BLACK LABEL SOCIETY
SHADOWS FALL
MUDVAYNE
IRON MAIDEN
BLACK SABBATH

Second Stage:

BURY YOUR DEAD
WICKED WISDOM
GIZMACHI
SOILWORK
IT DIES TODAY
ARCH ENEMY
TRIVIUM
THE BLACK DAHLIA MURDER
THE HAUNTED
A DOZEN FURIES
MASTODON
AS I LAY DYING
KILLSWITCH ENGAGE
ROB ZOMBIE

The Set List:

  1. Intro - Sabbath Medley

  2. N.I.B.

  3. After Forever

  4. War Pigs

  5. Dirty Women

  6. Fairies Wear Boots

  7. Medley: Symptom Of The Universe [instrumental] / Sweet Leaf [instrumental] / Electric Funeral

  8. Iron Man

  9. Black Sabbath

  10. Sabbath Bloody Sabbath [intro] / Paranoid

  11. Encore: Sleeping Village [intro] / Children Of The Grave

  12. Outro - Changes

[No "The Wizard" or "Into The Void"]